Guide
RGB vs CMYK: why print looks different
The blue that glows on your screen comes back from the printer looking tired. That is not a mistake by the printer: light and ink work in opposite ways. Here is what happens, and how to plan for it.
By Mark Stoumann ·
Every color you see on a screen is a mix of red, green and blue light. Every color on a printed page is light that bounced off paper after inks absorbed some of it. The two systems, RGB and CMYK, describe those two physical processes. Converting between them is not just a change of notation: some colors simply don’t exist on the other side.
Additive light, subtractive ink
RGB is additive. A screen starts dark and adds light. Red, green and blue at full strength make white; all three off make black. Anything that emits light, from a phone to a projector, works this way.
CMYK is subtractive. Paper starts white, and each ink subtracts part of the light reflected from it. Cyan absorbs red, magenta absorbs green, yellow absorbs blue. In theory the three together absorb everything and make black. In practice real inks fall short, so printers add a fourth ink, black (the K), for deeper shadows and crisp detail.
As Adobe’s documentation puts it, the two gamuts overlap without one containing the other: some screen colors can’t be printed, and some printed colors can’t be shown on a screen.
Gamut: which colors each side can reach
A gamut is the range of colors a device or color space can produce. Three matter for most designers:
- sRGB, the default color space of CSS and of hex codes. Every ordinary monitor can show it.
- Display P3, a wider space that modern phones, laptops and TVs can show all or nearly all of. It uses the same white point and tone curve as sRGB but more saturated red and green primaries, which cover about 36% more area on the standard CIE chromaticity diagram.
- A CMYK printing condition, which is never one fixed space. It depends on the press, the inks and above all the paper. Standard conditions have names: in Europe FOGRA51 (the profile “PSO Coated v3”) for premium coated paper and FOGRA52 for uncoated; in the US the GRACoL and SWOP conditions. Each has its own ICC profile, because the same inks give different colors on different paper.
The overlap is uneven. Colors well inside both gamuts, such as muted tones, skin tones and most grays, convert with little visible change. The most saturated screen colors are the ones that disappoint, as the example below shows.
A worked example: five screen colors on paper
To show what happens, we converted five sRGB colors with the Generic CMYK Profile that ships with macOS, then converted the result back to see how the print would look on screen. The table also shows the simple formula many converters use, and chroma, how colorful each color is, measured in OKLCH:
| Screen color | Simple formula | With a CMYK profile | Looks like | Chroma |
|---|---|---|---|---|
#0000ff blue | C100 M100 Y0 K0 | C88 M68 Y0 K0 | #2e5595 | 0.313 → 0.114 |
#00ff00 green | C100 M0 Y100 K0 | C42 M0 Y60 K0 | #94c883 | 0.295 → 0.109 |
#ff8000 orange | C0 M50 Y100 K0 | C0 M54 Y87 K0 | #e98540 | 0.186 → 0.148 |
#e879f9 pink | C7 M51 Y0 K2 | C31 M45 Y0 K0 | #a789b3 | 0.207 → 0.070 |
#000000 black | C0 M0 Y0 K100 | C74 M71 Y64 K87 | #0f0c0c | – |
Pure screen blue and green lose almost two thirds of their chroma, and the bright pink loses two thirds as well, turning a soft mauve. Orange holds up better, losing about a fifth, because warm oranges sit closer to what magenta and yellow ink can make. Notice too that the profile’s numbers are nothing like the formula’s: for blue it uses far less magenta, because 100% cyan with 100% magenta on top prints as violet, as Adobe’s overprinting guide notes. A different profile, for another press or paper, would give different numbers again.
Screen magenta, #FF00FF, fares no better than the pink: the same profile turns it into about C31 M59 Y0 K0, a muted mauve, though the simple formula promises pure magenta ink, C0 M100 Y0 K0.
Why a hex-to-CMYK formula is only an approximation
The conversion most websites use, ColorPeekr’s included, is the simple formula:
- K = 1 − the largest of R, G and B (each from 0 to 1)
- C = (1 − R − K) ÷ (1 − K), and the same for M with G and Y with B
It is neat and reversible, and the W3C’s CSS Color 5 draft uses exactly this formula for CMYK values without a profile. The same draft is clear about its limits: it is “necessarily approximate”, because it knows nothing about the inks, dot gain or the paper. The draft’s own example shows how far off it can be. The ink values C0 M81 Y81 K30 convert naively to #b22222, the CSS color firebrick. Run the same four numbers through a FOGRA39 press profile and they describe #b44432, a noticeably more orange, less intense red.
So treat formula values as a description of a color’s ink balance, not as press-ready numbers. They are good for a rough idea of how much of each ink a color needs, and to see that a color has no black in it at all; the profile decides the rest.
Rich black vs 100% K
The formula turns #000000 into C0 M0 Y0 K100: black ink only. On paper that is not fully opaque: Adobe notes that in large black areas, inks printed underneath can show through it. The answer is rich black: black ink with some cyan, magenta and yellow underneath. The macOS profile in the table above does this on its own, building black from all four inks, C74 M71 Y64 K87.
Two rules keep rich black out of trouble:
- Use it for large areas and big type only. Small text should stay 100% K. If four plates are even slightly out of register, thin letters get colored fringes; Adobe InDesign overprints 100% black by default for exactly this reason.
- Respect the ink limit. Every printing condition has a maximum total ink coverage, the four percentages added up. For PSO Coated v3 it is 300%. The profile’s black above adds up to 296%; a hand-made C100 M100 Y100 K100 would be 400%, far over the limit. Ask your printer for their rich black recipe.
Color profiles: the missing piece
An ICC profile is a file that describes how a device or printing condition reproduces color, in terms of a device-independent reference based on how people see. With a profile for your sRGB artwork and one for the printer’s condition, software can work out which CMYK values produce the closest visible match, and what to do with colors that are out of reach. That is the conversion the table above used, and the one a hex formula can’t do.
What to hand your printer
- Ask first. Which printing condition or ICC profile do they use for your paper? Do they want CMYK files, or RGB files with a profile that they convert themselves?
- Design in RGB, convert at the end with their profile, and soft proof before you do: Photoshop’s Proof Setup and similar tools show how colors will shift.
- Check your brand colors in the soft proof. If a vivid blue or pink is out of gamut, choose its print version deliberately rather than letting the conversion pick.
- Keep small text 100% K and use their rich black recipe for large areas.
- Order a hard proof for anything where color matters. Your screen, however good, is still emitting light.
For screen work, the color picker converts any color to HEX, RGB, HSL, OKLCH and the formula CMYK described above. To understand the screen formats themselves, read HEX, RGB, HSL and OKLCH explained.
Frequently asked questions
Should I design in RGB or CMYK?
For anything that ends up on a screen, RGB. For print, a common workflow is to design and edit in RGB, then convert to CMYK at the end with the profile your printer gives you, soft proofing along the way. Adobe recommends the same for Photoshop: edit in RGB first, convert to CMYK at the end. If your printer asks for CMYK files with a specific profile, follow their instructions.
Why does my print look duller than my screen?
A screen makes color by emitting light; paper can only reflect it, and inks absorb part of the light that falls on them. The range of colors ink on paper can reach, its gamut, is smaller than a screen’s in many directions, especially for saturated blues, greens and pinks. Those colors are mapped to the nearest printable color, which is less vivid.
Is there an exact CMYK value for a hex color?
No. CMYK numbers are instructions for a particular press, ink set and paper. The same hex color needs different CMYK values on coated and uncoated paper, and the same CMYK values print as different colors on different presses. An exact conversion needs the ICC profile for the printing condition you will use.
What is rich black?
Black ink mixed with some cyan, magenta and yellow, which prints deeper than black ink alone. Adobe suggests it for large black areas and large type, and recommends asking your print provider for the exact percentages, because the total amount of ink is limited by the press and paper.
Are ColorPeekr’s CMYK values accurate?
They come from the simple formula with no color profile, the same naive conversion the CSS Color 5 draft describes. That makes them a fair starting point and fine for rough reference, but not a replacement for converting with your printer’s profile.